Stakeholder - XS CAD Limited


Is BIM creating scope overlap in the M&E industry?

BIM-scope-overlap

The successful control of BIM models between consultants and contractors in the MEP (M&E) industry continues to be a challenge, and the question of ‘who does what’ has re-emerged now that parametric 3D model-based building services design and coordination processes are becoming more prominent.

Some of the benefits of BIM include: greater relationships among stakeholders, less constructability issues on-site, enhanced design performance and cost efficiency. To apply BIM, scope definition and delivery must be managed effectively, along with the collaboration between MEP (M&E) consultants, contractors, sub-contractors and shop fabricators. Despite its benefits, BIM can create scope overlap between these consultants, contractors and others involved, meaning the project could incur costs and even delays.

Usually, with 2D design data, services coordination and clash detection fall under the responsibility of the MEP contractor. They overlay each of the 2D drawings (for HVAC, electrical and plumbing services) and use either 3D or BIM tools to complete a detailed coordination exercise. A spatially coordinated model is the outcome, which could be used for the creation of installation drawings and later fittings/installations.

This 2D drawing deliverables method means design consultants do not have to focus on constructability and spatial coordination. Nevertheless, the BIM procedure requires clash-free 3D MEP models to be produced by MEP (M&E) BIM consultants before 2D designs drawings for contractors are created.

The consultant effectively carries some of the scope that contractors usually implement when they provide their BIM model (which is increasingly clash free and coordinated to some extent). Despite this, the model is not always coordinated in the way that services would be installed, nor is it cost effective for an MEP contractor.

There is a possibility that the 3D model contributed to the contractor may fall short, even if the consultants’ BIM MEP model is clash-free and spatially coordinated with the architectural and structural systems. The reasons for this are: I) acquisition changes for equipment and materials; ii) the model is unrepresentative of the layout or installation process; iii) inefficient layouts such as allowing for too many bends and connections; iv) inadequate allowance for lagging; v) inadequate allowance for installation/hanging; and vi) no allowance for entry for maintenance purposes. Overall, though spatially coordinated the consultant’s 3D model may be inadequate for installation.

If the BIM model is not revised to the contractor’s individual fitting and installation requirements these issues will only be encountered when in the field. By then, major changes cannot be made and installation will be compromised as reviews and revised/repeated model drawings will increase costs and fees. This is the main area of scope overlap and will affect project profitability and schedules.

This overlap can be seen as defeating the purpose of employing MEP (M&E) BIM methods. The scope can be reduced if more time is reserved to define the deliverables of all parties at the beginning of the process.

Three alternatives are offered to avoid such scope overlap. Firstly, the consultants may not focus on producing a coordinated or clash free model when creating their BIM model. They would then create their design drawings, providing the contractor with a model that has adequate routes and outlets for services, though it is not coordinated. This approach reduces the consultant’s BIM modelling time.

Secondly, a traditional, non-BIM era 2D design could be created. The project’s call for BIM will be served as it still permits the contractor’s to produce a BIM model. This method also means, if required, the contractor can use specialist MEP coordination firms to produce a coordinated BIM model.

The final approach is to employ a specialist MEP coordination firm that possess the required skills, such as knowledge of installation. This means the output could be more useful to contractors who can then perfect the model and create drawings.

Scope overlap in MEP projects can be reduced if one of these approaches is applied. Projects can also be managed and delivered more effectively during the pre-construction and BIM stages. This will be advantageous for clients and a more constructive and efficient use of BIM technology when delivering MEP BIM projects.

Contact Us

XS CAD Limited,

Greenlands Business Centre,

Studley Road,

Redditch,

Worcestershire

B98 7HD

United Kingdom

T: +44 (0)1527 518 880

E: info@xscad.com

www.xscad.com

facebook twitter googleplus linkedin

Featured Video

Testimonials


Our projects span numerous market sectors and are typically multi-disciplinary, which means that the engagement and collaboration across teams is vital when developing design models and drawings.  With XS CAD's assistance for building services design, we have had an excellent supply of skilled Revit professionals that not only compliment our team but added value to our overall building services offering and delivery.  I would have no hesitation in recommending XS CAD's team to other similar organisations as they provide a knowledgeable, professional and assiduous approach to building services that has surpassed expectations at BECA.



Andrew Jackson, Technical Director, Building Services – BECA Buildings

XS CAD has undertaken MEP Coordination services for MITIE Engineering. They are a professional concern and their costs are very competitive.  More importantly, they use 3d systems to validate their work. Their drawings have helped site teams immensely. I would not hesitate to recommend them.

Darron Jones, Managing Director, Mitie Engineering – Wales
See all
  • UK Construction Online’s Stakeholder page offers you the chance to find and learn about the leading companies in the UK Construction Industry.

    Featuring the very best suppliers and operators in the sector our stakeholder’s pages offer detailed information about the company, their latest case studies and press releases, plus products and services and testimonials.

    We work with our stakeholders to constantly update and maintain this database to ensure that the information is relevant and helpful for those looking to source premium quality companies in the UK construction market.

    You can ‘View all Stakeholders’ or use the drop down menus to find specific stakeholders via their company name or by sector.

    Join the Fastest Growing Community for Construction

    UK Construction Online's Stakeholder package quickly connects your company to our vast audience of over 250,000 visitors a month.

    View our latest Alexa ranking:

    What is a Stakeholder?

    A stakeholder is a Mircosite that has the power to highlight a product or service, launch a promotion, or promote brand awareness to the construction industry in a way that full websites or more traditional marketing cannot.

    All stakeholders have the ability to have their latest press releases and case studies promoted across the UK Construction Online platform. UK Construction Online is updated daily, with the latest news across all sectors within the construction industry and all stakeholders are promoted on both social media and to a mailing list of over 122,000 subscribers.

    UK Construction Media
    0800 6127680
    enquiries@promarkmedia.co.uk